I saw an article in Yahoo Finance about the old adage, “Sell in May and Go Away“. In the article the focus is on the period between May and October. But, does this mean May is a month to avoid? Hardly. Instead, our Chief Market Strategist Tom Bowley makes the opposite case as he laid out in his marketFORWARD section of our our most recent marketPULSE newsletter. Here’s a few nuggets of information you might want to consider:
1-On the S&P 500, May ranks 7th out of the 12 months in terms of performance since 1950
2-The past four decades have shown May gaining on average 7.83% on an annualized basis
3-Prior to 2010, the S&P had gains in 20 out of the previous 25 years
4-The Russell 2000 has finished higher than it began in May 16 of the past 24 years with an average annualized return of 17.96%
This year May looks like it could be setting up for higher prices as well. Today alone the Dow hit fresh four year highs, the VIX is showing signs of weakening, and the S&P is closing in on fresh 52 week highs..
So, the bottom line is that it makes no sense to just blindly bail out of the market in May; it’s a myth. And, in today’s fast pace market, active traders aren’t likely to hold positions for 6 months anyways, hoping that the market performs well. Instead, it makes more sense to analyze the market “in the moment”, letting history serve as a guide, not letting it be the last word.
(If you don’t already subscribe to our free newsletter here’s Tom’s latest article for everyone to enjoy!)
marketFORWARD – Published Sunday, April 29, 2012 by Tom Bowley
Monday marks the end of April with May right around the corner. Of course we all know that famous Wall Street adage “Go away in May!” Will it ring true again this year? The temptation to walk away from the stock market will definitely be there after the drubbing that U.S. equities have taken the past two years. But history doesn’t really support the argument to sell equities now. We don’t care what the parade of “experts” on CNBC say.
Rather than pay attention to the rhetoric, let’s discuss the ACTUAL numbers, shall we? On the S&P 500, May ranks 7th out of the 12 calendar months in terms of annualized performance since 1950. May has produced gains in 35 of 62 years during that span. While May’s annualized return of 2.79% trails the S&P 500′s average annualized return of approximately 8.5%, the last four decades have proven to be much closer to the norm, gaining 7.83% on an annualized basis — and this number includes the horrendous May 2010 and May 2011 results, where the S&P 500 fell 8.20% and 1.35%, respectively. The 2011 performance was aided by a strong finish during the last four days of May where the S&P 500 regained close to three full percentage points. The stock market really struggled throughout May in both of the last two years.
What you won’t hear on CNBC, however, is that the S&P 500 — prior to 2010 — had gained ground during the month of May in 20 of the previous 25 years. Does that sound like a bearish period to you? Furthermore, the Russell 2000 shows a VERY strong historical bias to the upside during May. In fact, the Russell 2000 has finished May higher than it began in 16 of the last 24 years, producing an annualized return of 17.96%. May trails only the months of December and April as the best performing month for small cap stocks.
Again, I’ll ask the question. Is May when you really want to go away? We don’t think so.
In fact, we’re of the opinion that the stock market is likely to break to fresh 52 week highs during May. There are some truly bullish signs that continue to emerge. Consumer discretionary stocks broke to a new relative high vs. consumer staples. That generally does not happen just prior to a market selloff. If anything, this type of relative behavior tells us that the 2012 rally is not over — that it is quite sustainable indeed. Check out the relative breakout in the consumer discretionary space:

The time to be concerned about a stock market advance is when money is moving on a relative basis towards the more defensive consumer staples sector. When this ratio is moving higher, as it is now, it’s an indication that investors are willing to commit to the higher risk consumer discretionary sector. In a bull market, you ALWAYS want to see investors scooping up the riskier areas of the market. So far, so good.
We mentioned the historical component of the market as we approach May, but it’s also important to note that the first week of May tends to be its best. For whatever reason, traders tend to have a bullish mindset as we usher in the month of May. Earnings will begin to slow down. There are still plenty of companies that will be reporting this week, but the most of the bigger names have already released their quarterly results. Still, it would be smart to check your companies for earnings dates to avoid the “big surprise”.
The market seems to be building up its resiliency to bad news again. Last week, we had the GDP shortfall, an S&P downgrade of Spain debt, the Netherlands unable to reach compromise on their budget issues, weak manufacturing data from China, Germany and France, political instability in France and another poor initial claims report. All of those bearish reports did nothing to slow down the bulls as technical buyers began buying right where they needed to. Price support on the S&P 500 was at 1357 and that index bounced at 1358. Take a look:

We’re expecting the market to add to last week’s gains. It’s hard to believe but another round of critical employment reports hit the Street this week as the ADP Employment Change report is released on Wednesday, initial claims will be out on Thursday and the biggie, the government’s Nonfarm Payrolls report is due out on Friday. All of these reports will be out during pre-market action so make sure you tune in. So long as the BIG intermediate-term price support levels aren’t lost, we remain clearly in a bull market. The levels to watch to the downside include the following:
S&P 500: 1340
NASDAQ: 2881
Russell 2000: 773
Happy trading!